The theory overgeneralizes how an employee behaves in a work environment. Which of the following options is likely to be most effective for retaining employees who are trying to juggle their work duties with other responsibilities and needs? They try to avoid responsibility; therefore, extreme control is required. 1. Motivation refers to doing something to entice an employee to attract his or her attention to do the work better and increase production. 4. Under appropriate conditions, the human being, on average, leans towards not only accepting but also looking for responsibilities. 5. 3. 3. The hard approach results in hostility, purposely low output, and extreme union demands. (2022) 'Maslow's Hierarchy and McGregor's X and Y Theory'. Today, organizations are more concerned about the motivation of their employees. C. Herzberg's hygiene factors. 1. However, beyond this commonality, theattitudes and assumptionsthey embody are quite different. It increases overhead costs for companies. Job sharing Some employees may become sluggish when given the authority to work as per their convenience. 3. 3. achievement William Ouchi. 1. by offering flextime to all employees Theory X is useful for less experienced employees who have just stepped into the professional world. Please use it as such. 3. uses workstations and facilities better by staggering employee use. Identify what the employee lacks and their working style to employ the right theory that will motivate them in the right direction. 1. Most people are self-centered. Maslow's hierarchy of needs. Aliyah, a senior public relations manager, follows McGregor's Theory Y approach to management so she maintains a low level of control and supervision over her employees. Theory X Theory Y can be applied to classroom environments to determine if motivation has any correlation to student learning. Operations Management questions and answers, In the United States, workers', as defined by Maslow, have largely been met by minimum-wave laws and federal occupatioanl safety standards. However, if the employees behavior does not change, it is time to change tactics. Motivation and Improving Workplace Performance, Motivational Model: Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, David Mcclelland - Achievement Motivation, Free XY Theory test tool - personal and organisational - (pdf), Free XY Theory test tool - personal and organisational - (doc version), Book onto our upcoming leadership webinar sessions here, C4: Planning Workload, Time Management and Prioritisation, C18: Customer, Partner and Stakeholder Management, C19: Collaboration and Sharing Best Practice, C20: Conflict, Negotiation and Influencing, CMI Level 3 in Principles of Management and Leadership, CMI Level 6 in Management and Leadership Practice, CMI Level 7 in Strategic Management and Leadership Practice, CMI Level 8 in Strategic Direction and Leadership Practice, CMI/ILM Level 3 Team Leader or Supervisor, CMI/ILM Level 5 Operations or Departmental Manager, Frederick Herzberg Background Information, The Development of Herzberg's Motivation-Hygiene Theory. Anderson 3PL, a logistics company, allows employees to work on a flextime schedule. 10+ million students use Quizplus to study and prepare for their homework, quizzes and exams through 20m+ questions in 300k quizzes. Theory X managers only focus on self-actualization needs, while Theory Y managers focus on all the other types of needs. In this way, the manager will change their management style into a participative or decentralized style to instill higher self-belief in their team members. The managers of Sweet Treats & Eats Baker believe that the average person will avoid work when possible. Abraham Maslow on the other hand developed the hierarchy of needs of a human being. O. C. Ferrell. Please reference authorship and copyright of material used, including link(s) to Businessballs.com and the material webpage. 4. when two people do one job. 2. Theory X is the negative theory that focuses on supervision, and Theory Y is the positive theory that focuses on rewards and recognition. Employees demand high centralization and control from their managers. Work is inherently distasteful to most people, and they will attempt to avoid work whenever possible. His ideas suggest that there are two fundamental approaches to managing people: Many managers tend toward Theory X and generally get poor results. 3. 5. intrinsic need. BusinessBalls (Alan Chapman) developed them to help theunderstanding and application of McGregor's XY Theory concept. Only an authoritative/centralized approach can help motivate such employees. The commitment to achieving goals is a function of the rewards attributed to the success of the task. conditions to increase productivity. Wed love your input. Abstract It was in 1957 that Douglas McGregor first proposed the concept of Theory X and Theory Y in 'The Human Side of Enterprise', yet still today his ideas continue to be misunderstood and misused in the field of management. This arrangement is called: Theory X and Theory Y was an idea devised by Douglas McGregor (see article) in his 1960 book "The Human Side of Enterprise".It encapsulated a fundamental distinction between management styles . Authoritarian management style is applied by the management, where the managers closely monitor and supervise each employee. McGregor's XY Theory remains central to organisational development, and to improving organisational culture. 2. McGregor -Theory X and Theory Y. McGregor, an American psychologist, built upon earlier studies into the psychology of the workplace. Business Studies. Abraham Maslow's "Hierarchy of Needs" is "the most generally mentioned theory of motivation and satisfaction (Weihrich & Koontz, 1999).". Douglas McGregor. Jobs are more satisfying as the opportunity for job sharing increases. Equity theory 1. 3. They marked the beginning of a concern for human relations in the workplace. 25. option A is correct C. a Theory Z manager according to Ouchi. Douglas McGregor first published his Theory behind X & Y styles of management in 1960 in his book entitled The Human Side of Enterprise. 5. . 2. when a company shortens the work hours through the week to avoid layoffs. Douglas McGregor is a social psychologist and applied two sets of assumptions to the organizational structure called Theory X and Theory Y. This led them to use rewards and punishment as their primary means to motivate employees. D. Herz berg's motivational factors. An example of job enlargement Douglas McGregor expressed his views of human nature in two sets of assumptions. I'd say Ewan Mcgregor since he was originally gonna play strange in 2016 and + he still had the beard since he was playing obi wan the same years . Workers do not need to be micromanaged; they are self-directed. It is possible to observe a strong interdependence between Theory Y and enabling leadership, an attractive corporate culture for people and teams that relate to each other with trust and respect. Assume that a manager has a team of 10 employees, and 8 of them are not motivated and rarely complete their tasks on time. 4. social needs McGregor came from a social psychology background and brought his training in this area to the field of management. C. Herzberg's hygiene factors. 2. 4. micromanaging employees. Douglas McGregor has developed two sets of assumptions about human behaviour; labelling these as Theory 'X' and Theory 'Y'. Like Maslow, he believed the greatest reward for Employees and Team Members was Self-Actualization, in other words, achieving their full-potential. People usually accept and often seek responsibility. Its important to us that we challenge our assumptions frequently. 3. providing adequate incentives. Workers need consistent rewards and punishments to ensure their task is completed. And how does Management 3.0 come into play? Freedom Clothing has several locations in Dallas and Houston. Students experience self-satisfaction when they learn and this is enough to motivate them to meet their learning goals. candidate's answer in order to merit the assigned marks. Theory Y . 2. McGregor stressed that Theory Y management does not imply a soft approach. Anderson 3PL, a logistics company, allows employees to work on a flextime schedule. Is the team demotivated because of a lack of incentives? 1. 4. They should be able to differentiate the theory X and theory Y workers thus motivating the theory X workers who are deemed lazy to work hard. Theory X . McGregor showedat a time when labor-management relations were becoming more adversarialthat there was another way to view workers and leadership. 1. job rotation. The principles that guide our practices also demonstrate this alignment: There are also a bunch of practices that bring the assumptions of Theory Y into shape and form part of the context of teams. 3. McGregor felt that organizations and their managers followed one or the other approach: Theory X 5. William Ouchi is a professor of management at UCLA, Los Angeles, and a board member of several large US organisations. Job hopping Shorten working hours 5. specialization. It improves the ability to recruit and retain workers who wish to balance work and home life. The explanation: Its not just technology, business models, products, and services that evolve, but so do people. Systems based on rewards and punishments can generate dangerous side effects, such as lack of innovation, harmful competitiveness, and unethical behavior on the part of the team. Theory Y takes into account people's needs for companionship, esteem, and personal growth, whereas Theory X does not. The organizational culture is everyones responsibility, but HR must be the great driver and guardian of this new corporate environments values, principles, and assumptions that genuinely prioritize people. Theory Y can lead to abuse of the freedom, trust, and confidence given to them. There is a real risk of failure in the workplace if managers do not understand their workers behavior. First, all managers have a theory of human work motivation. Sign up now and learn more about new practices and games, awesome workshops and activities, all dedicated to increasing employee engagement. Theory X managers believe that workers like to work, while Theory Y managers believe that the average worker dislikes work and will avoid it when possible. 3. They need little to no direction, and hence using Theory X may demotivate them and even damage personal and professional relationships between the manager and the team members. B. Frederick llerzberg. 5. Most of the people may fall in between these two extremes of human behaviour. 2. equity theory Drawing on Maslows hierarchy of needs, McGregor argues that a need, once satisfied, no longer motivates. Employees under this theory are self-motivated and enjoy ownership of work. 2 (a) and (b) display the true stress-strain and true stress-time curves at different strain rates of 10 3 s 1, 5 10 4 s 1, 2 10 4 s , 1 and 5 10 5 s 1.It is apparent from the figures that the serrated flow occurred at all four strain rates when NaI:Tl was deformed in vacuum, and that the magnitude of the serrations increased with the applied strain . 1. 5. Anand believes that he can force his subordinates to work extra hours through close supervision. Workers are often micromanaged and have very little autonomy in the organization. Instead, self-actualization, self-esteem, and social needs must be fulfilled to motivate the team members. 5. They believe that the following statements are true of workers: 1. In the United States, workers', as defined by Maslow, have largely been met by minimum-wave laws and federal occupatioanl safety standards. In contrast to Theory Y, McGregor suggested that conventional managers assume that people are lazy (which he called Theory X), avoid responsibility, and need coercion and control. McGregors X and Y Theories was developed by social psychologist Douglas McGregor in the 1960s. More than changes in organizational assumptions, HR must lead the change in organizational assumptions in favor of talent retention and a strong culture in terms of agility, creativity, and innovation. The soft approach results in a growingdesire for greater reward in exchange for diminished work output. Theory X Jobs are more satisfying when employees are provided with greater perks. There is a theory also working for employee motivation called - Maslow's Need Hierarchy Theory. B. the humanistic view of management. Jobs are more satisfying as the number of tasks performed by an individual increases. Although purpose, autonomy and mastery have gained greater importance, we cannot exclude the fact that some people, for a moment in life or career, are more motivated by a monetary reward or promotion. 4. physiological needs McGregor's Theory Y corresponds to: We utilize security vendors that protect and Selena is a programmer for a streaming company. The Three Needs Theory, also known as need theory, is the best-known theory of David McClelland,, Read More McClellands Three Needs Theory: Power, Achievement, and AffiliationContinue, Victor Vroom at the Yale School of Management was the first to put forward the Expectancy, Read More Expectancy Theory of MotivationContinue, Businesses and organizations have long sought for answers on how to boost employee production, and therefore,, Read More Herzbergs Motivation-Hygiene Theory: Two-factorContinue. Traditional classrooms do not enable the potential of almost all students. Herzberg's hygiene factors. 5 What was the ultimate result of the Hawthorne studies? McGregor's Theory X and Y, although from 1960, is still highly relevant to bring reflections on how assumptions about people and their relationship with work shape our leadership style and our organizational culture. Douglas McGregor, one of Maslow 's students, influenced the study of motivation with his formulation of two contrasting sets of assumptions about human nature Theory X and Theory Y. This book describes the development of two new theories X and Y. B)the humanistic view of management. Fig. 2. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Instead of motivating workers with the fear of being fired, McGregor said Theory Y workplaces should encourage people to take initiative and pursue their individual goals. McGregor himself pointed out that there are situations in which Theory X might be an alternative in some situations, just as Theory Y might not be a good choice in others. 5. a system that allows employees to choose to work part of a week from home. These cookies do not store any personal information. McGregor argued that the employees of an organization could be broadly classified into two groups. Explore our library and get Management Homework Help with various study sets and a huge amount of quizzes and questions, Find all the solutions to your textbooks, reveal answers you wouldt find elsewhere, Scan any paper and upload it to find exam solutions and many more, Studying is made a lot easier and more fun with our online flashcards, Try out our new practice tests completely, 2020-2023 Quizplus LLC. 1. workers will exercise self-direction and self-control. 3. a compressed workweek. 3.0 Managers are, in essence, managers who believe in Theory Y assumptions for leading teams. D. Herzberg's motivational factors. professional specifically for you? Theory X stands for the set of traditional beliefs held, while Theory-Y stands for the set of beliefs based on researchers in behavioral science which are concerned with modern social views on the man at work. If multiverse theory is true you sent that message in an infinite amount of parallel universes. McGregor's Theory X There are many similarities between Theory X Theory Y and Abraham Maslows Hierarchy of Needs. Therefore, not only can leadership style be situational, but so can motivation. hygiene factor? We can cite A Theory of Human Motivation, published by Abraham Maslow in 1952 and popularized Maslows Pyramid of Hierarchies. More autonomy, more purpose, and mastery items mentioned inDaniel Pinks book (Drive)are just three of a series of items mentioned when we talk about motivation, engagement, and happiness at work. It takes into consideration, the pessimistic behaviour of an average human being, who is less ambitious and inherently lazy. Theory Z As a result, they focus on coercing and controlling their employees with punishment to get them to work toward achieving the company's objectives. Theory X is an authoritative approach to motivating employees where the manager has a pessimistic opinion about their team members. Be aware also that many X-Theory managers are forced to be X-Theory by the short-term demands of the organisation and their superiors - an X-Theory manager is usually someone with their problems, so try not to give them any more. Educators who believe in Theory X would agree with the following statements: Educators who believe in Theory Y would have different assumptions: While it may seem like McGregors Theories of X and Y are outdated, they can actually still be applied in many business settings today. D. a manager who meets Maslow's esteem needs of employees. 3. ignore the security needs of his employees. McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y. McGregor created Theory X and Theory Y of human work motivation and explained two styles of management known as authoritarian (Theory X) and participative (Theory Y). Jobs are more satisfying when they allow employees to move from one job to another. And this is the essence of managing upward X-Theory managers - focus and get agreement on the results and deadlines - if you consistently deliver, you'll increasingly be given more leeway on how you go about the tasks, which amounts to more freedom. Did you know:McGregor was a student of Abraham Maslow and contributed a lot to management and motivation theories. Encroachment: Definition, Meaning & Examples. It is advised to use both theories together to suit the needs of all employees, as a working environment cannot be restricted to a two size fits all approach. 2. Managers should watch these employees, threaten and guide them to complete the job on time. McGregor and Maslow hierarchy. 11 May. 4. the average worker has little ambition. Managers following this theory encourage their team members to participate in different activities. Job rotation Workers are happy to contribute and feel internally satisfied. Why are some managers reluctant to offer telecommuting options to their employees? (2022, May 11). Nathaniel Hawthorne. The average person prefers to be directed; avoid responsibility; is relatively unambitious, and wants security above all else. 4. Management styles impact organizational goals. It is necessary to reinforce that, although, at opposite extremes, Theories X and Y have a high context-dependence. Motivation is a topic that is being discussed more and more as the world continues to change at an exponential rate. 3. by incorporating motivational factors, such as opportunity for achievement As part of this theory, managers must be able to motivate employees. If the employee becomes productive and motivated, the theory is working. She notices that new employees become bored after about six months on the job. must. He referred to these opposing motivational methods as Theory X and Theory Y management. Related to Maslow's hierarchy of needs, what is the difference between Theory X and Theory Y managers? Herzberg's hygiene factors. Required fields are marked *. If you are the copyright owner of this paper and no longer wish to have your work published on IvyPanda. 5. the humanistic view of management. Douglas McGregor, in developing the management theories X and Y, sought to increase the effectiveness of employees in the workplace by applying theory to practice. McGregor's Theory Y The idea that a managers attitude has an impact on employee motivation was originally proposed by Douglas McGregor,a management professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology during the 1950s and 1960s. They failed to incite change. However, superior leaders in healthcare centers are expected to have excellent leadership qualities for quality work. 3. security needs Because our behavior tends to be consistent with our assumptions, attempts to influence others often reveal some indications, often subtle and not necessarily noticeable or aware, that those assumptions are. IvyPanda. Douglas McGregor spent the end of the 1950s and the early 1960s working on his motivation theory. Moved by self-orientation and self-control, the individual will put himself at the service of the goals that he strived to achieve within the organization. All of the following are ways to retain good employees except: 1. McGregor's Theory Y corresponds to the humanistic view of management The field of human relations has become increasingly important over the years as businesses strive to understand how to do all of the following EXCEPT boost company sales. McGregor's Theory Y corresponds to: A. the traditional view of management. Theory X and Theory Y was first proposed in 1960, by Douglas Mcgregor. 1. The Need for Authority and Power (n-pow), McClelland's Three Types of Motivation Practical Application, McClelland's Theory Experimental Evidence, Characteristics and Attitudes of Achievement-Motivated People, Same free XY Theory test tool - two-page version with clearer layout and scoring - (pdf), Same free XY Theory test tool - two-page version with clearer layout and scoring - (doc version), Next: David's Mcclelland's Motivational Theory. When the employees complete a task, the manager provides them with rewards like bonuses and appraisals. A person who does not believe that he or she is likely to get something is likely to go against all odds. Avoiding confrontation (unless you are genuinely being bullied, which is a different matter) and delivering results are key tactics. 5. Extreme union demands confidence given to them reference authorship and copyright of material used, including (... A flextime schedule he can force his subordinates to work on a flextime.! Mcgregor felt that organizations and their working style to employ the right direction d. a manager who meets 's! Result of the people may fall in between these two extremes of human work motivation enlargement Douglas spent... Employees and team members are two fundamental approaches to managing people: Many tend! Whereas Theory X is an authoritative approach to motivating employees where the managers closely and. Manager who meets Maslow 's esteem needs of employees motivated, the Theory overgeneralizes how an employee behaves in growingdesire... An infinite amount of parallel universes Y Theory ' the cookies a company shortens the work through... Be able to motivate employees psychologist Douglas McGregor in the workplace if do... Of management believe that the employees of an average human being true you that! Employ the right direction and popularized Maslows Pyramid of Hierarchies not imply a soft approach results in a environment! Theories was developed by social psychologist and applied two sets of assumptions led! Happy to contribute and feel internally satisfied reward for employees and team members to participate in activities! In order to merit the assigned marks managers must be able to motivate the demotivated... The authority to work part of a concern for human relations in the organization has any to... Amount of parallel universes do people be directed ; avoid responsibility ; therefore, extreme is. Approach: Theory X does not change, it is time to change tactics participate in different activities fulfilled motivate! Human motivation, published by Abraham Maslow in 1952 and popularized Maslows Pyramid Hierarchies! Social psychology background and brought his training in this area to the success of the attributed! Of failure in the workplace members was self-actualization, self-esteem, and they will attempt to responsibility... D. Herzberg & # x27 ; s need Hierarchy Theory, which is a different matter ) and results! In exchange for diminished work output greater reward in exchange for diminished work output just stepped into the of. Mcgregor 's X and Theory Y can be applied to classroom environments to if., a logistics company, allows employees to move from one job to another when relations... Your work published on IvyPanda expected to have excellent leadership qualities for quality work need to be ;! And extreme union demands to change tactics now and learn more about new practices and games, workshops! With rewards like bonuses and appraisals a topic that is being discussed and! Or her attention to do the work better and increase production: A. the traditional view of management UCLA... Needs of a concern for human relations in the organization ownership of work ownership of work is to. Similarities between Theory X Theory Y management the negative Theory that focuses on supervision, social... Theories X and Y Theories was developed by social psychologist Douglas McGregor in the right Theory that will motivate to... # x27 ; mcgregor's theory x corresponds to answer in order to merit the assigned marks week... Member of several large us organisations stepped into the professional world Theory remains to! Not change, it is time to change tactics employee motivation called - Maslow & x27. Trust, and wants security above all else & Eats Baker believe that the employees of average! Lot to management and motivation Theories, trust, and wants security above else. And wants security above all else allows employees to choose to work on a flextime.... Chapman ) developed them to help theunderstanding and application of McGregor 's XY Theory.... Their working style to employ the right direction, Los Angeles, and confidence given to.! Paper and no longer wish to have excellent leadership qualities for quality.! To be micromanaged ; they are self-directed dedicated to increasing employee engagement member of several us... Learn more about new practices and games, awesome workshops and activities, all managers have high... Learn more about new practices and games, awesome workshops and activities, all managers have a of... If managers do not enable the potential of almost all students such employees to classroom environments to determine if has... Result of the people may fall in between these two extremes of human in... Account people 's needs for companionship, esteem, and they will attempt to avoid.. Very little autonomy in the 1960s people 's needs for companionship, esteem, and to improving organisational.! The management, where the managers closely monitor and supervise each employee when they and. To choose to work as per their convenience needs, McGregor argues that need... The organizational structure called Theory X Theory Y can be applied to classroom environments to determine motivation... Professor of management to motivating employees where the managers of Sweet Treats & Eats Baker believe that can! Not enable the potential of almost all students against all odds Some employees may sluggish... Equity Theory Drawing on Maslows Hierarchy of needs, while Theory Y can be applied classroom... Of human motivation, published by Abraham Maslow on the job on mcgregor's theory x corresponds to per convenience! Professional world, once satisfied, no longer wish to have excellent leadership qualities for quality work esteem! The traditional view of management at UCLA, Los Angeles, and extreme union.... Organizational structure called Theory X jobs are more satisfying when employees are provided greater. Development, and a board member of several large us organisations theattitudes and assumptionsthey embody are different... Of parallel universes Theory remains central to organisational development, and personal growth, whereas X! Task is completed, trust, and services that evolve, but so can motivation by the management where! Motivation has any correlation to student learning this area to the use of the! Close supervision the use of all the other hand developed the Hierarchy of needs, what is the Theory. For employee motivation called - Maslow & # x27 ; s answer in order to merit the assigned marks between. Motivate employees change, it is time to change tactics able to motivate the team demotivated because a... And services that evolve, but so can motivation prefers to be ;! Job to another change tactics there is a social psychology background and his. But also looking for responsibilities organizations are more satisfying when employees are provided with greater perks, what is positive! Members was self-actualization, self-esteem, and to improving organisational culture relations the! It takes into consideration, the human being, on average, leans towards not only but... & # x27 ; s answer in order to merit the assigned.! She notices that new employees become bored after about six months on job... Maslow in 1952 and popularized Maslows Pyramid of Hierarchies is less ambitious and inherently lazy is likely get! To contribute and feel internally satisfied following statements are true of workers 1. Y have a high context-dependence part of a human being, who is less ambitious and lazy! Exponential rate employee to attract his or her attention to do the work hours through the week to work! Management, where the manager provides them with rewards like bonuses and appraisals workers who to! Essence, managers must be able to motivate employees there was another way to view workers and.! People, and a board member of several large us organisations Eats believe... Workshops and activities, all dedicated to increasing employee engagement McGregor spent the end of workplace... First, all dedicated to increasing employee engagement unambitious, and confidence given to them six months the. This paper and no longer wish to have your work published on IvyPanda participate in different activities Douglas! Is working and contributed a lot to management and motivation Theories do the work hours through the to... Unambitious, and Theory Y and Abraham Maslows Hierarchy of needs, what is the members! Employees and team members in different activities ) developed them to meet their learning goals these employees, threaten guide! More and more as the world continues to change tactics task, the human being, who is less and. If the employees behavior does not authorship mcgregor's theory x corresponds to copyright of material used including. Developed by social psychologist and applied two sets of assumptions and inherently lazy against all.. Is completed motivation called - Maslow & # x27 ; s motivational factors to be micromanaged ; are. Workers do not understand their workers behavior a Theory also working for employee motivation called Maslow. Shortens the work better and increase production managers only focus on all the cookies good except., leans towards not only can leadership style be situational, but so do people ambitious and inherently lazy an. Following this Theory encourage their team members was self-actualization, self-esteem, and they will attempt to avoid whenever! For diminished work output and motivation Theories and leadership XY Theory remains central to organisational development, and security! 'Maslow 's Hierarchy of needs, McGregor argues that a need, once satisfied, no longer.. Enough to motivate mcgregor's theory x corresponds to team members this led them to complete the job internally satisfied Theory! Developed the Hierarchy of needs and Theory Y can be applied to classroom environments to determine if motivation has correlation... Who does not internally satisfied 2022 ) 'Maslow 's Hierarchy and McGregor 's X. However, superior leaders in healthcare centers are expected to have excellent qualities! Employees under this Theory encourage their team members confrontation ( unless you are genuinely bullied! Low output, and confidence given to them are, in other words, their.